Tribunal ruling reinforces how accountants and innovators must demonstrate that “R&D must be impactful on the field as a whole”, advises expert R&D tax consultants

Tribunal ruling,Environmental Services Ltd (ESL)
Contents

A recent First Tier Tribunal (FTT) ruling indicates that a lack of awareness of HMRC’s guidelines on R&D tax reliefs and uncertainty around what a qualifying claim would contain might still be a persistent problem in the sector, cautions leading R&D tax consultant, randd uk.

The Environmental Services Ltd v HMRC [2026] UKFTT 01301 (TC) case highlighted a number of issues relating to the credible allocation of costs and the presentation of work undertaken.

Environmental Services Ltd (ESL) was unsuccessful in its attempt to overturn HMRC’s rejection of the claim, with the FTT taking issue with the allocation of costs while remaining unconvinced that the work advanced the relevant field of science or technology.

Technical Director at randd uk, Adam Bointon, observed the ways in which the tribunal ruling could help to illustrate the realities of an R&D tax relief claim for both accountants and innovative businesses.

“Given that the claim is from 2020 and 2021, ESL had to wait three years for the case to go to tribunal despite it lacking the evidence required to make such a case successful,” Adam said. “One of the biggest areas that would need to have evidence is with the assignment of costs.

“ESL attempted to claim 80 per cent of their competent professional’s salary costs in one year and 50 per cent the next. This means that he would have had to have spent that portion of time exclusively doing R&D work on that specific project.

“This would be viewed as quite high, given that most people do have other matters to attend to throughout the working day, so evidencing the accuracy of this would be essential.”

Complications can arise when ascribing qualifying expenditure costs – while an estimate can be used in some instances, clear evidence must demonstrate that the apportionment is just and reasonable.

However, randd uk is hoping that businesses that do break the norm with R&D expenditure are prepared to evidence this carefully, as HMRC are likely to grow suspicious of these types of inclusion.

Hugh Wragg, R&D Compliance Manager at randd uk, added: “Businesses who believe in their innovation do have a right to defend their case, but knowing the likelihood of success can help temper expectations.

“Even among experts, there may be some debate as to what may constitute R&D for tax purposes – only a true competent professional in the field can adjudge a qualifying advancement and uncertainty.

“Good R&D tax relief advisory support enables a competent professional to do that while also assisting clients with apportionment methods for all costs.

“What matters most when compiling an R&D tax relief claim is that it results in a credible case that is defendable in an enquiry.”

Only through an understanding of the CIRD guidelines, the metric by which HMRC judges the legitimacy of an R&D tax relief claim, can an accountant or innovator be confident in a claim.

The FTT noted that “ESL failed to establish that it was seeking an advance” and only provided evidence that it “undertook practical problem-solving in response to operational and commercial challenges rather than projects directed towards achieving an advance in science or technology within the meaning of the Guidelines.”

Hugh said: “Something that is often misunderstood is the extent to which R&D must be impactful on the field as a whole.

“Work that purely benefits just the business undertaking it will likely be viewed as routine or commercial and therefore ineligible for receiving the kind of Government support that is bestowed through R&D tax reliefs.”

While HMRC’s decision was upheld, the FTT made some important criticisms of the original verdict that may influence the way other R&D tax relief claims are prepared.

Whereas HMRC rejected ESL’s competent professional and claimed the business had no plan, the FTT noted that having “approximately 40 years’ practical experience” proved that he “possessed substantial expertise in the relevant field” and the FTT accepted him as “a competent professional for the purposes of this appeal.”

“HMRC prioritises qualifications over experience when determining the validity of a competent professional’s claim to knowledge,” Hugh said. “Its own guidance indicates that extensive experience is sufficient and this returns to the issue of needing to evidence as much of a claim as possible.

“While it may be apparent that someone conducting innovative work for decades should be seen as a competent professional, having tangible signs of their expertise, such as collaboration with other experts, attendance of conferences, awards they have earned, or something similar, can support an R&D tax relief claim.”

A similar ruling was made regarding the plans that underpinned the claim, with HMRC’s suggestion that no written plan was cause for rejection being disputed by the FTT on the grounds that it was clear the competent professional had a plan, albeit not written down.

In terms of how the tribunal ruling affects R&D tax reliefs more broadly, Adam noted: “As it is not possible to be an expert in every field, neither an agent nor HMRC are the true arbiter of what counts as R&D for tax purposes. However, both need to be able to demonstrate their logic to a judge if necessary.

“A judge can only decide the validity of a claim based upon evidence presented and the balance of probability of whether it meets the CIRD guidelines or not.”

R&D tax consultants are well placed to assist with this given the extensive familiarity with the guidelines they possess.

“Our team work with accountants and innovative businesses across a range of sectors, helping those engaging with the scheme to understand the guidelines and how best to present their case,” said Adam. “We sense-check all claims, ensuring that all associated costs are credible, the project aligns with HMRC’s criteria and that there is logical methodology behind these elements.”

randd uk advises accountants and businesses to seek support before attempting to compile an R&D tax relief claim. Knowing ahead of time whether something is valid R&D can save time and money, while the expert support of randd uk’s expert R&D tax consultants ensures that all qualifying costs are captured in the R&D tax relief claim.

Adam Bointon is a Technical Director specialising in R&D Tax Credits for SMEs in manufacturing and software sectors. With over 15 years’ experience, he works closely with businesses to identify qualifying R&D activities and prepare clear, compliant claims. He combines technical expertise with a strong understanding of economics and finance to support successful outcomes. Adam also contributes to industry webinars and CPD sessions, sharing insights on R&D tax relief and HMRC requirements.

Sign up to our Newsletter

Stay ahead with the latest R&D tax insights, funding updates, and innovation trends - straight to your inbox.

[contact-form-7 id="2d41ad2" title="Newsletter Signup"]

Recent insights

Ready to discuss your unclaimed R&D Tax Credits?

Complete the form to request a call from one of our consultants or click here to send us a message.