How should businesses prepare evidence for an R&D tax relief claim?

How should businesses prepare evidence for an R&D tax relief claim?
Contents

With a recent tribunal ruling highlighting the importance of having robust evidence to support R&D tax relief claims, accountants looking to help clients make the most of the relief may face more questions about satisfying these criteria.

While there are a variety of different ways to support an R&D tax relief claim, it is necessary to understand the most effective ways of gathering evidence to safeguard original claims and provide a stronger basis for enquiry defences when needed.

As R&D tax consultants, we aim to support accountants in helping clients with R&D and part of this process is making you aware of some effective strategies for evidence gathering.

What evidence is needed to support an R&D tax relief claim?

At the core of any R&D tax relief claim is the need to verify that the project conducted does qualify as R&D for tax purposes.

The issue with this is that the exact way in which something would meet the criteria is often viewed differently depending on who is assessing the claim, so it is necessary to have enough evidence in place to justify the belief that it is valid.

In essence, it may be that HMRC agents have differing opinions on what counts as R&D, but operating in close alignment with HMRC’s guidelines ensures that a claim is protected should it be subject to an enquiry.

As such, hitting each of the points of contention with solid evidence is often the best way to approach matters.

This means having a range of evidence, from things that are fairly straightforward to prove, like the work took place in a specific period of time, to that which may be more challenging to show, like how it advances the overall knowledge of science or technology.

How should evidence be managed in an R&D tax relief claim?

Knowing how to handle the evidence gathered for an R&D tax relief claim requires having an in-depth knowledge of the R&D tax relief claim process, as this empowers an innovative business to be proactive in evidence gathering.

The best time to gather evidence is while the research is taking place.

While it might seem like this means businesses will need to complete the onerous task of documenting every second of research, there is a balance that can be struck.

Contemporaneous evidence such as emails, meeting minutes, internal reports, presentations and photos can be useful to show that the project took place within the financial period being claimed for and when the project started and ended.

In a perfect world, a business would be able to accurately record the number of hours spent on a project by the competent professional so as to better assign the costs associated with their employment, as well as tracking how much energy and water were used during the R&D.

However, HMRC accepts a fair and reasonable apportionment provided that there is evidence to support the approach.

Clear records of materials consumed in the process of the R&D allow an innovative business greater access to consumable costs, while knowing how to demonstrate that the work was truly innovative better safeguards the entire claim.

A competent professional should be able to indicate the state of knowledge at the start of the project and how the work sought to push that knowledge to a previously unknown state.

From there, a technical narrative can be created, detailing the efforts put in and the setbacks that may have been incurred throughout the process.

It is this trial-and-error approach that further enhances an R&D tax relief claim, as HMRC needs to understand how the work was not readily deducible to a competent professional.

Accountants should not take this as an indication that only the most iron-clad R&D tax relief claims are successful.

Apportioned costs can often rely on reasonable estimates, but the more evidence gathered, the easier it will be to handle an enquiry – though a successful defence is often possible even with limited evidence.

Should a client face an enquiry and there is a lack of clarity on what evidence would help to resolve the matter, our team are particularly skilled at handling these situations.

Alongside compiling R&D tax relief claims that capture the full scope of innovation and qualifying costs, we can handle enquiries with confidence so that legitimate value is preserved.

By working with us, accountants and innovative businesses get a better idea of what evidence can help R&D tax relief claims be processed more efficiently without the concern that they may be rejected due to missing information.

For a clearer vision of how to gather evidence for R&D tax relief claims, get in touch with our team.

Adam Bointon is a Technical Director specialising in R&D Tax Credits for SMEs in manufacturing and software sectors. With over 15 years’ experience, he works closely with businesses to identify qualifying R&D activities and prepare clear, compliant claims. He combines technical expertise with a strong understanding of economics and finance to support successful outcomes. Adam also contributes to industry webinars and CPD sessions, sharing insights on R&D tax relief and HMRC requirements.

Sign up to our Newsletter

Stay ahead with the latest R&D tax insights, funding updates, and innovation trends - straight to your inbox.

[contact-form-7 id="2d41ad2" title="Newsletter Signup"]

Recent insights

Ready to discuss your unclaimed R&D Tax Credits?

Complete the form to request a call from one of our consultants or click here to send us a message.