Care home tribunal ruling “a lesson to all innovators,” cautions top R&D tax consultants

tribunal ruling,Tanglewood,Care home
Contents

Innovative businesses and the accountants that support them may have overlooked the key takeaways from the recent First Tier Tribunal (FTT) ruling in the case of Tanglewood Care Services Limited, the operator of a residential care home.

HMRC had rejected the R&D tax relief claim by the care home, disallowing the spending of £880,286 on the grounds that no valid R&D work was conducted.

Tanglewood believed that attempts to minimise the spread of disease during the pandemic were novel and while the FTT praised the work conducted by the care home, it concluded that managing operational challenges was not the same as advancing scientific knowledge.

Due to the implementation of external guidance and scientific discoveries only constituting a system uncertainty, the FTT confirmed that no valid R&D work had been completed and many of the vital components for an R&D tax relief claim were absent – including a competent professional in the relevant field of science or technology.

Leading R&D tax consultant, randd uk, agrees with the decision but has noted that some of the key points discussed in the tribunal apply more broadly to the sector and should not be ignored.

Hugh Wragg, R&D Compliance Manager at randd uk, said: “The business featured in the tribunal case operated in a sector that is ineligible for R&D and lacked a competent professional, so HMRC’s rejection of the claim was understandable and reasonable.

“However, other businesses may fall into a similar trap of thinking the work they do is innovative and dismiss the findings of this tribunal by not going beyond the headline.”

Hugh highlights the need for businesses to consult the guidance before attempting to compile an R&D tax relief claim. Where confusion may persist around the validity of the work undertaken, using the Advanced Assurance Scheme or engaging with an R&D tax consultant is better than submitting an erroneous claim.”

The guidance clearly delineates between routine activities that are ineligible and those that are genuine advances and can be part of a valid claim. A simple way of telling the difference is by questioning whether the issue extends beyond what is thought to be possible within the current understanding of science and technology – if the work goes beyond that, it is likely to qualify.

Inspiration can strike different businesses as new challenges arise, so even those not traditionally invested in science and technology should not necessarily view the tribunal ruling as a barrier.

“While Tanglewood are part of a social science sector and the work is generally ineligible, there are instances where advances occur outside of the traditional sectors,” Hugh explained.

“We have worked with a college who were able to innovate in the field of audio-visual technology, a client who mainly did social science work but developed a novel piece of software and psychologists who were able to achieve an advance in data processing.

“The commonality between these, and the thing lacking in the Tanglewood case, is a genuine advance in the field of science or technology overseen by a competent professional. Each of the claims we worked with either had a competent professional in-house or brought one in for the duration of the project.”

An absence of a competent professional was noted as one of the critical flaws in the Tanglewood case. However, many businesses are unclear about who counts as a competent professional.

“A competent professional is someone who is an expert due to qualifications, experience or both,” Hugh explained. “While HMRC favours qualifications as evidence, there is no denying that an engineer who has been innovating for decades should be viewed as an expert.

“If Tanglewood had brought in an expert virologist to seek a novel way of containing the spread of disease then there is a possibility it could have qualified – though the project would have looked very different.”

The tribunal ruling is the latest example of the more compliance-focused HMRC that has been able to root out much of the error and fraud within the R&D space. Enquiries have been the main catalyst for this improvement and have led to the value of R&D claims increasing while the amount submitted declines.

“We have positioned ourselves as experts in compliance support, both through the way we put together our R&D tax relief claims and how we defend clients from enquiries,” said Hugh. “While other R&D tax consultants have a compliance rate, the amount of claims subject to enquiry, between three and six per cent, ours is comfortably below one per cent.

“Our team is the best in class, backed up by knowledge and experience that you would struggle to find elsewhere.

“More R&D takes place than people realise, but there is a limit to what can be accepted by HMRC. We conduct thorough health checks throughout the process and support accountants as well as innovative businesses.”

randd uk advises accountants and businesses to seek support before attempting to compile an R&D tax relief claim. Knowing ahead of time whether something is valid R&D can save time and money, while the expert support of randd uk’s expert R&D tax consultants ensures that all qualifying costs are captured in the R&D tax relief claim.

Adam Bointon is a Technical Director specialising in R&D Tax Credits for SMEs in manufacturing and software sectors. With over 15 years’ experience, he works closely with businesses to identify qualifying R&D activities and prepare clear, compliant claims. He combines technical expertise with a strong understanding of economics and finance to support successful outcomes. Adam also contributes to industry webinars and CPD sessions, sharing insights on R&D tax relief and HMRC requirements.

Sign up to our Newsletter

Stay ahead with the latest R&D tax insights, funding updates, and innovation trends - straight to your inbox.

[contact-form-7 id="2d41ad2" title="Newsletter Signup"]

Recent insights

Ready to discuss your unclaimed R&D Tax Credits?

Complete the form to request a call from one of our consultants or click here to send us a message.